Yahoo News claims that the ad is "more than just a commercial -- it was more like a message." The journey of the farmer, featured in the ad, captures the viewer on his path of self discovery. He goes from fattening his stop-motion-animated piggies with chemicals and sending them off to slaughter houses to a revelation that sends him "back to the start."
By no means, is the ad meant to convince customers to become vegetarian- as Chipotle uses a variety of meat in its menu. Rather, the ad is geared toward showing Chipotle's importance of using the finest free-range meat in its burritos and other products.
Although the ad has received a lot of attention from the general public after its Grammy debut, professionals in the advertising industry recognized its greatness while it was still in the dark to most. Ad Week listed the spot as #2 on its list of top ten ads of 2011. The ad was topped only by Volkswagen's "The Force." Ad Week called Chipotle's ad "a marvel of craft, visually and musically."
"The Scientist" cover art from iTunes.com |
Although the majority of feedback from the ad has been positive, it has spawned a few critics. One is Zap2it who finds the commercial somewhat unsettling.
I tend to prefer Qdoba over Chipotle, but for this debate, sign me up for team Chiptole. I disagree with what Eckstein writes. Yes, what he said is essentially what the commercial is doing, but the overall concept of the ad shows Chiptole just as they had hope it would- cultivating a better world.